Personalized Medicine vs One-Size-Fits-All Health Care: Importance of Individual Biology
Learn about the differences between personalized medicine and traditional medicine and why genetics, lifestyle, metabolism, and biological makeup matter in medicine.

Two patients may be diagnosed with the same condition, lead an almost similar life style, yet react completely differently to the same therapy.
One patient reacts positively to it. The second requires a completely different strategy. The third develops side effects or continues experiencing the symptoms even when his or her “test results” are normal.
Why? Because the diagnosis is not the whole patient.
The genetics, medical background, lifestyle, environmental factors, metabolism and other elements of individual biology may increase a person’s likelihood of becoming sick and the way the body reacts to the treatment.
This is what personalized medicine, also known as precision medicine, is all about.
Instead of believing that the same treatment works equally effectively on everybody, precision medicine takes into account individual features of each person.
What Is One-Size-Fits-All Medicine?
Historically, healthcare has been built around the principle of providing care based on how well things work for the typical patient.
This principle still holds enormous value. Standardised guidelines, effective treatments, and evidence-based approaches underpin medicine today.
But there is no such thing as the “typical patient” in the clinic setting.
Patients can vary in:
- Genetics
- Age and sex
- Previous illnesses
- Family history
- Lifestyle
- Diet
- Sleep habits
- Stress levels
- Environmental factors
- Metabolism
- Other medication or diseases
The National Institutes of Health defines precision medicine as “an emerging approach for disease treatment and prevention that takes into account individual variability in genes, environment, and lifestyle for each person.”
This is not about abandoning traditional medicine. It’s about making your medical decisions as precise as possible for the patient in front of you.
What Exactly Is Personalized Medicine?
The term may seem more futuristic than what it actually is.
Personalized medicine doesn’t necessarily imply that every single patient will have a treatment that is totally unique and tailored just for them.
Many times it involves using additional data to determine which kind of treatment or preventative strategy would be best suited for an individual or a certain group of individuals.
This could include the following:
- Symptoms and clinical history
- Family history
- Blood markers
- Metabolic health
- Lifestyle choices
- Environment exposure
- Genetics where relevant
- Previous responses to treatment
It must be noted that according to the National Research Council, precision medicine usually entails identifying subgroups of patients with different disease risks or responses to treatments rather than developing personalized treatment for each individual.
Why Is Individual Biology Important?
Consider two individuals having the same disease.
Their diagnoses can be exactly the same.
Their biology does not necessarily have to be the same.
Different genetics, different metabolism, co-morbidities, medications, and different lifestyle/environmental factors can affect the course of a particular disease and the reaction to treatment.
The field of pharmacogenomics is one example.
Some genetic polymorphisms can determine the rate of drug metabolism and even predispose an individual to experiencing certain adverse events. There are many such gene-drug relations listed in the FDA database of pharmacogenomic associations when the evidence was enough.
This is why the question is not always about: “What treatment works for this disease?”
Sometimes it’s rather about: “What treatment will work for this particular patient?”
Personalized Medicine is Not Only About Genetics
The very first association of the term “personalized medicine” for most people is that of DNA testing.
Genetics is certainly significant, but it is just one part of the equation.
In many cases of chronic and metabolic disorders, the factors like:
- Blood glucose control
- Insulin resistance
- Lipid profile
- Blood pressure
- Body composition
- Sleep
- Nutrition
- Exercise
- Stress
- Hormonal balance
They are quite useful from the clinical standpoint. And in preventive and metabolic medicine, in particular, the early signs can occur even prior to the development of an actual disease.
The approach of Dr. Sudeepta Rao takes into account all these issues while creating personalized treatment plans.
How Does This Play Out With Metabolic Wellbeing?
Metabolic wellbeing is an excellent example of how individual physiology makes a difference.
Two individuals can have the same body weight but vastly differing metabolic status.
One will have normal blood pressure and normal glucose and lipids.
The other individual will have growing waist size, higher triglyceride levels, insulin resistance or high blood sugar levels.
If focus is put solely on body weight, the difference is going to be overlooked.
Likewise, the individual suffering from tiredness or gaining weight without a reason may actually have entirely different underlying issues – thyroid problems, lack of sleep, malnutrition, insulin resistance, etc.
Preventive health care philosophy practiced by Dr. Sudeepta stresses identifying early metabolic changes through proper clinical examination and appropriate biomarkers.
Do We Need More Testing in Personalized Medicine?

Absolutely not! This is a critical point.
A personalized approach does not mean doing every single test possible.
It is not true that more data equals better data.
The key here is to choose the tests which are clinically meaningful for a particular patient.
As Dr. Sudeepta’s website indicates, “an evaluation usually starts with regular lab testing, additional validated testing depending on symptoms, health history and personal health goals.”
Ideally, the approach needs to follow: The right data. For the right patient. At the right time.
Why Does Individualization Matter?
Individualization could assist clinicians in:
1. Early identification of risks
Certain metabolic disorders or other chronic diseases tend to progress slowly. Checking the corresponding markers would allow the identification of changes before they manifest.
2. Understanding why a therapy is failing
In case there are persistent symptoms that do not go away even after receiving a certain therapy, reconsideration of the diagnosis, causes, and other aspects might be needed.
3. Decreasing the number of interventions
The goal of precision medicine is to find the right matches between therapies and those individuals that could benefit from them.
4. Prevention of diseases
Instead of diagnosing a certain disorder when it is already well-established, personalized risk identification will allow for timely interventions.
Does Personalized Medicine Have Limitations?
Certainly. Personalized medicine holds great promise, yet it is not a panacea for all ailments.
Not all genetic variations have proven clinical importance. Not all sophisticated testing leads to improved outcomes. The degree of clinical evidence differs by ailment and technology used, and practical application may be hampered by financial constraints and availability.
This is the reason why personalized medicine should stay grounded in clinical evidence.
The aim of any test should be to answer a relevant clinical question, not collect data.
So What Does All That Mean For You?
The personalization of medicine does not mean that standard medicine should be tossed aside.
Rather, it involves asking different questions.
Not only should the question,
“What is the standard approach to treating this condition?”
be asked, but
“What do we know about the patient’s background?”
“What risk factors do they possess?”
“How are their bodies reacting?”
“What other factors play a role here?”
Also need to be considered.
In Conclusion
You may have a diagnosis with a name. But your biology has a narrative.
Today’s medicine already has great standards and guidelines for treatment. Personalized medicine offers one more level: discerning which differences matter for an individual patient.
For the simple reason that modern healthcare does not need to be about choosing between science and personalization.
Modern healthcare needs to be about using science to understand the person better.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is personalized medicine the same as precision medicine? Yes, the two terms are often used synonymously. However, NIH uses the term ‘precision medicine’, which considers personal differences in genetic makeup, environment, and lifestyle to influence medical care.
2. Is personalized medicine genetic testing?
No. While genetic data might be helpful at times, personalized medical practice takes into account many different clinical aspects such as medical history, signs and symptoms, lifestyle, metabolic biomarkers, medication and many others.
3. Is personalized medicine superior to conventional medicine?
Not necessarily. Personalized medicine is an approach that may be helpful in customizing preventive, diagnostic and therapeutic interventions on the basis of individual factors.
4. Can personalized medicine assist in managing chronic diseases?
It may prove helpful in managing and/or preventing some chronic illnesses taking into account individual risk factors, treatment response and causative agents. However, it depends on the type of disease and evidence base.
5. Is there a need for advanced health testing for everyone?
No. It must be done on the basis of clinical relevance, symptoms and risk factors only.